Authoritative or Authoritarian Parenting

Dr. B: Are you an authoritarian or authoritative parent?

Parent: What’s the difference?

Dr. B: All the difference in the world.

Parent: Oh. Oh. What have I done wrong now?

Dr. B: Don’t get defensive. Besides, this is confidential. No one else is listening. 

Parent: Well, that’s a relief.

Dr. B: Are you a, “Because I said so” kind of parent?

Parent: Sometimes. Especially when I’m frustrated with dawdling or backtalk. 

Dr. B: You don’t like backtalk?

Parent: Who does?

Dr. B: What bothers you about it?

Parent: Well, to begin with, it’s disrespectful. No kid should be able to talk back to their parent. 

Dr. B: So. Shouldn’t talk back to parents or teachers or police officers?

Parent: Heavens, no!

Dr. B: How about bullies or abusive roommates? 

Parent: Well, I certainly teach my kids how to handle themselves in a fight.

Dr. B: How do they know when they have a right to speak up?

Parent: They need to respect their elders.

Dr. B: What if their elders are wrong or abusive?

Parent: What are you getting at?

Dr. B: If you want your kids to be able to take care of themselves, they need to know they are entitled to be heard and respected. 

Parent: Well, yeah. 

Dr. B: So if you make a rule they think is unfair, are they allowed to say something about it?

Parent: I try to be fair with my rules.

Dr. B: But what does it take to change a rule?

Parent: When I think they are old enough.

Dr. B: What if they think they are old enough?

Parent: I’m clear with my rules. For example, I tell them, you can’t use that tool until you are 14. 

Dr. B: What if your kid wants to show you they are responsible enough to handle the tool, but they are still 13? 

Parent: I tell them, “It’s only a year away. Be patient”. 

Dr. B: What if they turn 14, but are not responsible enough to handle it?

Parent: What’s your point? This is getting old in a hurry.

Dr. B: An authoritative parent sets rules that are necessary for safety, and explains why the rules are necessary.

Parent: And?

Dr. B: And is willing to change the rule when the child shows they are responsible enough for a change to be made. 

Parent: So, you’re saying that I’m authoritarian parent? As in dictator?

Dr. B: A benevolent dictator, for sure. 

Parent: I haven’t got another minute.

Dr. B:Didn’t think so.

Author: ahbtest

Dr. Beitel has decades of experience as a therapist, teacher and parent since earning his Ph.D. from the University of Illinois. As a member of the University of Illinois medical school faculty, Dr. Beitel supervises psychiatry residents in training. He is married to "the other Dr. Beitel", a family physician. He and Joyce have two grown children.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Childproofing for Adolescence

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading